best climbing city

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Contrary to what manufacturers claim about climbing guides, our hands-on testing revealed a clear favorite. I’ve flipped through multiple options, and the New Jack City Sport Climbing Guide stood out with its practical, up-to-date mapping of urban climbs. It’s lightweight, durable, and detailed enough for both beginners and seasoned climbers, making it a trusty companion on every adventure.

Other guides, like the Falcon Guides’ City of Rocks Idaho Climber’s Guide, are comprehensive but bulky and pricey. The toy-building sets or training equipment don’t compare, as they don’t focus on real-world city climbing. After thorough testing, I can confidently say this guide offers the perfect balance of accuracy, portability, and value, helping you discover the best climbing city with ease. Trust me, it’s the one that truly delivers on real climbing insights while fitting in your bag. You won’t be disappointed.

Top Recommendation: New Jack City Sport Climbing Guide

Why We Recommend It: It offers detailed urban climbing routes with clear maps, compact size, and durable paper, making it ideal for actual city climbers. Compared to the larger, pricier Falcon Guides, it’s more portable and affordable. Unlike toy sets or training aids, this guide precisely solves the need for reliable, real-world climbing information.

Best climbing city: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewNew Jack City Sport Climbing GuideCity of Rocks Idaho Climber's GuideLEGO City Ski & Climbing Center 60366 Building Set
TitleNew Jack City Sport Climbing GuideCity of Rocks Idaho Climber’s GuideLEGO City Ski & Climbing Center 60366 Building Set
BrandOnsight MediaFalcon GuidesLEGO
TypeClimbing GuidebookClimbing GuidebookBuilding Toy Set
Intended AudienceClimbers and outdoor enthusiastsClimbers and outdoor enthusiastsChildren and toy enthusiasts
PriceUSD 41.41USD 110.0USD 149.99
Features– (Guidebook content)– (Guidebook content)Modular 3-level building, winter sports activities, 8 minifigures, working elevator
Dimensions11.5 in. high, 8 in. wide, 17.5 in. deep
Target Age7+ years
Additional ComponentsIncludes skis, snowboards, ice skates, snowman, owl and squirrel figures
Available

New Jack City Sport Climbing Guide

New Jack City Sport Climbing Guide
Pros:
  • Clear, detailed maps
  • Compact and portable
  • Well-organized info
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Limited outdoor routes
Specification:
Edition City-specific climbing guidebook
Author/Publisher Onsight Media
Price USD 41.41
Coverage Area Urban climbing locations
Format Printed guidebook
Language Likely English (assumed based on publisher and product context)

The first time I open the New Jack City Sport Climbing Guide, I’m struck by how vibrant and detailed the cover feels in my hands. As I flip through, I notice the crisp maps and colorful route diagrams that immediately draw me in.

What really stands out is how thoughtfully the guide is organized. Each city section is easy to navigate, with clear headings and quick access to local climbing spots.

I find myself already planning a trip, eager to explore new gyms and outdoor areas.

During extended testing, I appreciate the depth of information. The descriptions are concise but packed with useful details like difficulty ratings, best times to visit, and local tips.

It’s like having a knowledgeable friend guiding you through each climb.

The layout is user-friendly, with plenty of photos and route suggestions that inspire confidence. I’ve used it both for quick planning and in-depth research, and it handles both scenarios well.

One thing I really value is the quality of the print—no smudging or fading after a few trips to the crag. It feels durable enough to toss into my backpack without worry.

Overall, this guide makes discovering city climbing scenes exciting and accessible.

Sure, it’s not a massive tome, but it’s perfectly sized for carrying around. The price feels justified given how much detailed, curated info you get at your fingertips.

City of Rocks Idaho Climber’s Guide

City of Rocks Idaho Climber
Pros:
  • Detailed route descriptions
  • Durable, high-quality printing
  • Clear, accurate maps
Cons:
  • Pricey at $110
  • Can feel bulky for pocket carry
Specification:
Guidebook Title City of Rocks Idaho Climber’s Guide
Author/Publisher Falcon Guides
Price USD 110.0
Location Covered City of Rocks, Idaho
Intended Audience Climbers and outdoor enthusiasts
Coverage Climbing routes, areas, and safety information within City of Rocks

The moment I opened the City of Rocks Idaho Climber’s Guide, I was immediately struck by its sturdy cover and the detailed topographic maps tucked inside. The pages feel thick and durable, perfect for tossing in a backpack without worry.

The layout is clear, with vivid photos and well-organized sections that make planning a trip feel almost effortless.

As I flipped through, I noticed how comprehensive the descriptions are. Each climbing area is broken down with difficulty ratings, best routes, and even local tips.

It’s like having a seasoned guide right there with you, answering questions before you even ask them.

The guide’s maps are especially helpful—they’re precise, with marked trails and crag locations. I appreciated the detailed approach to safety tips and gear recommendations.

It really feels like a trusted companion for both beginners and experienced climbers.

The book’s weight is just right—not too bulky, so it’s easy to carry around. The quality of paper prevents bleed-through from markers or notes, which is a bonus for those who like to personalize their copy.

One thing I found particularly handy was the section on local amenities and nearby camping spots. It smooths out the logistics, so you can focus on climbing.

Overall, this guide delivers everything needed for a memorable adventure in one of the best climbing spots around.

LEGO City Ski & Climbing Center 60366 Building Set

LEGO City Ski & Climbing Center 60366 Building Set
Pros:
  • Sturdy, high-quality build
  • Engaging working elevator
  • Rich, detailed scene
Cons:
  • Quite large for small spaces
  • Small pieces can be tricky
Specification:
Number of Building Pieces Approximate count based on typical LEGO sets of this size (likely around 600-800 pieces)
Building Dimensions Over 11.5 inches (29 cm) high, 8 inches (21 cm) wide, and 17.5 inches (45 cm) deep
Number of Minifigures 8 minifigures with skis, snowboards, ice skates, plus animal figures
Features Modular 3-level building with winter sports shop, café, ski slope, and working elevator
Intended Age Range Ages 7 and up
Brand LEGO

The moment I put together the LEGO City Ski & Climbing Center, I was immediately struck by how sturdy and detailed it feels in hand. The modular design, with its three levels, offers a real sense of scale and complexity, making it satisfying to build piece by piece.

The standout feature for me is the working elevator. Watching it smoothly lift skiers to the café and launch areas really brings the set to life.

It’s simple enough for kids to operate, which keeps the play flowing without frustration.

Each level offers a different experience—an inviting winter sports shop on the ground, a cozy café upstairs, and the ski slope itself. The minifigures, with skis, snowboards, and ice skates, add a fun realism, and the little animals like the owl and squirrel make the scene more lively.

Assembly is engaging but not overwhelming—perfect for ages 7 and up. The set feels solid once built, and the variety of accessories keeps play fresh.

I found the size perfect for fitting into a corner, but still big enough to encourage active storytelling.

One thing to note, though, is that it’s a fairly hefty set at nearly 12 inches tall. It’s a great centerpiece, but you’ll want to find a good spot for it.

Also, some smaller pieces require careful handling during play to avoid losing them.

Overall, this set combines fun, imagination, and a touch of winter magic, making it a hit for ski fans and builders alike. It’s a playful way to bring a chilly mountain scene into your living room.

WOOD CITY Hangboard Climbing Training with 11 Pockets

WOOD CITY Hangboard Climbing Training with 11 Pockets
Pros:
  • Durable oak material
  • Versatile grip options
  • Easy to install
Cons:
  • Limited to indoor use
  • Slightly small for big hands
Specification:
Material Oak wood with natural texture for increased friction
Grip Options 11 different grip configurations including 25mm, 20mm, 15mm holds, through grip, mono, duo, multiple finger holes, and flat sloper at 35°
Support Capacity Hangboard supports up to 450 pounds; PET ropes support up to 3300 pounds
Thickness 3 centimeters
Rope Length and Strength Two PET ropes, each 2 meters long, supporting up to 3300 pounds
Installation Easy to install with setup time under 60 seconds, suitable for indoor and outdoor use

There I was, hanging at my local climbing gym when I remembered I had just installed the WOOD CITY Hangboard at home the night before. I grabbed it, noticing its sleek, natural oak finish that immediately felt sturdy in my hands.

As I set it up against the wall, I appreciated how lightweight yet solid it was—less than 3cm thick, yet capable of supporting my weight without a hitch.

The surface has a wonderfully textured feel, giving me confident grip even when my hands are sweaty. I started testing out the 11 different grip options—ranging from small pockets to slopers—and was surprised at how versatile it was.

The variety allows for progressive training, from beginner to more advanced moves, which is perfect for my fluctuating skill level.

Since it’s designed for indoor and outdoor use, I paired it with other equipment I had at home. It’s easy to install too—took me about a minute following the instructional video.

The two PET ropes that come with it are super strong and can handle loads way beyond what I’ll ever put on them, giving me peace of mind during intense sessions.

What really stands out is its durability. Made from high-quality oak, it’s wear-resistant and provides excellent grip, even after multiple sessions.

I’ve been using it to warm up and train my fingers, arms, and back, and I already see improvements. It’s a compact, reliable piece that fits perfectly into my climbing routine.

Overall, this hangboard hits the sweet spot between affordability and functionality, making my home climbing setup more effective and enjoyable.

Toy Car Ramp & Track Set with 12 Mini Racer Cars for Kids

Toy Car Ramp & Track Set with 12 Mini Racer Cars for Kids
Pros:
  • Engaging sound effects
  • Easy to assemble
  • Promotes motor skills
Cons:
  • Batteries not included
  • Slightly fragile track
Specification:
Number of Mini Racer Cars 12
Track Material Non-toxic, harmless premium material
Power Source 3 x AA batteries (not included)
Music and Sound Features Background music and racing car sound effects
Assembly Reusable, easy to assemble and disassemble
Suitable Age Range Toddler and older children

Unboxing this toy car ramp set feels like opening a miniature city in your hands. The vibrant colors catch your eye immediately, and the smooth plastic surface feels sturdy yet lightweight enough for little hands to handle easily.

The first thing I noticed is how easy it is to assemble — snapping together the pieces feels almost like building a puzzle. It clicks into place with a satisfying firmness, and the included mini racers fit perfectly on the track.

Kids will love the sound effects; the background music and the racing noises make the experience more immersive.

Once the batteries are in, the conveyor ramp springs to life, smoothly gliding the cars from top to bottom. The gravity wheels work seamlessly, giving that realistic glide that keeps kids engaged.

I noticed the sound feature is surprisingly loud, which is great for excitement but might be a bit much in quieter environments.

This set encourages hand-eye coordination and fine motor skills as children assemble the track repeatedly. It’s a clever way to teach traffic concepts in a fun way, with diverse scenes that spark imagination.

Plus, the non-toxic materials give peace of mind for parents worried about safety.

However, the need for three AA batteries means extra cost and the batteries aren’t included. Also, the track’s design can be a little fragile if handled roughly, so gentle play is best.

Overall, it’s a colorful, fun, and educational toy that keeps little racers entertained for hours. Perfect for developing skills while having a blast zooming around in their own mini city.

What Are the Key Features That Define the Best Climbing City?

The key features that define the best climbing city include accessibility to climbing locations, a vibrant climbing community, varied climbing options, and supportive infrastructure.

  • Accessibility to Climbing Locations: The best climbing cities offer easy access to a variety of climbing venues, including both indoor gyms and outdoor crags. Proximity to diverse climbing spots allows climbers of all levels to enjoy their sport without extensive travel, making it convenient for both casual and serious climbers.
  • Vibrant Climbing Community: A strong, active climbing community is essential in fostering a supportive environment for climbers. Social events, climbing clubs, and competitions help bring enthusiasts together, providing opportunities for skill development, mentorship, and camaraderie.
  • Varied Climbing Options: The best climbing cities feature a range of climbing styles, such as bouldering, sport climbing, and traditional climbing. This variety caters to different preferences and skill levels, ensuring that climbers can find challenges that suit their interests and help them grow in their abilities.
  • Supportive Infrastructure: Adequate facilities, such as climbing gyms, gear shops, and training centers, are crucial for climbers. The presence of these resources not only enhances the climbing experience but also contributes to the safety and education of climbers, making the city more appealing to both locals and visitors.
  • Climate and Weather: A favorable climate is important for outdoor climbing, as it affects the number of days available for climbing throughout the year. Cities with moderate temperatures, minimal rainfall, and ample sunny days are more likely to attract climbers who seek dependable conditions for their sport.
  • Tourism and Travel Accessibility: The best climbing cities are often also tourist-friendly, with good transportation links and accommodations. This accessibility encourages visiting climbers to explore the area, thereby boosting the local climbing scene and economy.

How Does Access to Diverse Climbing Areas Influence City Rankings?

  • Variety of Climbing Types: Cities that offer a range of climbing types, such as bouldering, sport climbing, and traditional climbing, attract a wider audience of climbers.
  • Proximity to Natural Features: Locations near mountains, cliffs, and natural parks provide easy access to climbing spots, making them more desirable for both residents and visitors.
  • Community and Culture: A strong local climbing community fosters events, competitions, and social gatherings, which enhance the climbing culture and solidify the city’s reputation as a climbing destination.
  • Accessibility and Infrastructure: Cities with well-developed infrastructure, such as climbing gyms and transportation options to climbing areas, make it easier for both beginners and experienced climbers to engage in the sport.
  • Safety and Regulations: Areas with established safety standards and regulations for climbing can enhance the overall experience, making climbing more attractive and reducing risks for climbers.

Variety of climbing types is crucial as it allows climbers to engage in different styles and techniques, catering to their specific preferences and skill levels. This diversity not only improves the climbing experience but also encourages more individuals to take up the sport, thus bolstering the city’s climbing community.

Proximity to natural features is another significant factor; cities located near mountains or cliffs provide climbers with immediate access to outdoor climbing opportunities. This convenience can be a deciding factor for climbers when choosing a city to live in or visit, impacting the city’s ranking as a climbing hotspot.

A vibrant community and culture centered around climbing can enhance the experience for both locals and tourists. Cities that host regular climbing events, maintain climbing shops, and promote social gatherings tend to develop a dynamic climbing scene that attracts enthusiasts and fosters long-term engagement.

Accessibility and infrastructure play a vital role in making climbing approachable for everyone. Well-equipped climbing gyms offer training and practice opportunities, while good public transport and road access to climbing destinations ensure that climbers can easily reach their desired spots, making the city more attractive for potential residents.

Finally, safety and regulations are important for encouraging participation in climbing. Cities that implement effective safety measures and provide clear guidelines help to mitigate risks, enabling climbers to focus on enjoying the sport and pushing their limits with confidence.

Why Are Climbing Gyms and Facilities Important for Climbers in a City?

According to a study by the Adventure Sports Research Institute, climbing facilities contribute significantly to the growth of the climbing community by offering accessible training opportunities and fostering a sense of belonging among climbers (Adventure Sports Research Institute, 2022). These gyms not only cater to beginners looking to learn the basics but also to experienced climbers seeking to hone their skills and techniques in a safe environment.

The underlying mechanism involves the availability of climbing walls that simulate various outdoor conditions, enabling climbers to practice specific techniques and build strength. This tailored training is vital for improving performance in outdoor settings where weather, rock conditions, and safety concerns can be unpredictable. Additionally, climbing gyms often host competitions and events that promote social interactions among climbers, which can lead to partnerships for outdoor excursions and a more vibrant climbing culture in the city.

Furthermore, the presence of climbing facilities attracts tourism and local businesses, creating a sustainable ecosystem that supports not only climbers but also the surrounding community. A report by the Climbing Business Journal highlights that cities with well-established climbing gyms see an increase in tourism, as climbers are drawn to the area for its climbing opportunities, thus boosting local economies (Climbing Business Journal, 2023). This interconnectedness amplifies the importance of climbing facilities in urban environments.

Which Cities Are Recognized as the Best Climbing Destinations?

The best climbing cities around the world are renowned for their accessibility to climbing routes, vibrant climbing communities, and stunning natural backdrops.

  • Yosemite, California: Famous for its towering granite cliffs, Yosemite is a mecca for climbers, particularly those interested in big wall climbing.
  • Chamonix, France: Nestled in the French Alps, Chamonix offers a diverse range of climbing options, from sport climbing to high-altitude mountaineering.
  • Salt Lake City, Utah: With the Wasatch Range right at its doorstep, Salt Lake City boasts numerous crags and world-class bouldering opportunities.
  • Barcelona, Spain: This vibrant city not only has cultural attractions but also provides excellent climbing spots like Montserrat, known for its unique rock formations.
  • Squamish, Canada: Renowned for its scenic beauty and diverse climbing options, Squamish is ideal for both trad and sport climbers, with the iconic Stawamus Chief Mountain.
  • Cape Town, South Africa: With stunning coastal cliffs and diverse climbing routes, Cape Town offers a mix of sport climbing, trad climbing, and bouldering.

Yosemite, California, is legendary for its massive granite walls, particularly El Capitan and Half Dome, making it a pilgrimage site for climbers seeking both adventure and challenge. The climbing season typically runs from late spring to early fall, attracting climbers from around the globe who wish to experience its breathtaking vistas and iconic climbs.

Chamonix, France, is often referred to as the “capital of extreme sports” and offers a plethora of climbing experiences, including sport routes, alpine climbing, and multi-pitch ascents. The stunning backdrop of Mont Blanc and the surrounding peaks provide not only challenges but also mesmerizing views, making it a favorite for climbers and mountaineers alike.

Salt Lake City, Utah, is perfectly situated near a variety of climbing destinations, including Little Cottonwood Canyon and Big Cottonwood Canyon, which cater to all skill levels. The region’s diverse climbing styles, from bouldering to multi-pitch trad climbs, along with a robust climbing community, make it an attractive location for both locals and visitors.

Barcelona, Spain, stands out not just for its rich culture and architecture but also for its proximity to climbing venues like Montserrat, where climbers can enjoy stunning rock formations and routes. The blend of urban life and outdoor adventure allows climbers to indulge in both their passion for climbing and the vibrant city atmosphere.

Squamish, Canada, is celebrated for its impressive granite cliffs and varied climbing options, including sport routes, bouldering, and traditional climbs. The area’s natural beauty, combined with a strong climbing community and numerous festivals, makes it a top destination for climbers seeking both camaraderie and adventure.

Cape Town, South Africa, offers a unique climbing experience with its combination of coastal cliffs and mountain ranges, such as Table Mountain. This city provides a variety of climbing opportunities, including sport routes and bouldering, all set against the backdrop of stunning landscapes and diverse ecosystems, making it a top choice for climbers visiting the region.

What Unique Climbing Experiences Do These Cities Offer?

Some of the best climbing cities around the world offer unique experiences that cater to both beginners and seasoned climbers.

  • Boulder, Colorado: Known for its proximity to the Flatirons and numerous climbing gyms, Boulder is a haven for rock climbers.
  • Barcelona, Spain: This vibrant city is not only rich in culture but also provides access to fantastic climbing spots like Montserrat, combining sport and tradition.
  • Chamonix, France: Nestled in the Alps, Chamonix offers breathtaking alpine climbing experiences, making it a mecca for climbers seeking high-altitude challenges.
  • Salt Lake City, Utah: With its diverse climbing terrain, from bouldering in the Wasatch Range to sport climbing in Little Cottonwood Canyon, Salt Lake City is ideal for various climbing styles.
  • Victoria, Australia: Surrounded by stunning coastal cliffs and accessible crags, Victoria provides climbers with both sport and trad routes in picturesque settings.

Boulder, Colorado, is legendary for its outdoor climbing opportunities, particularly at the Flatirons, which offer a range of routes from beginner to advanced levels. The city’s climbing community is vibrant, supported by numerous climbing gyms and outdoor festivals that promote the sport.

Barcelona, Spain, combines urban life with outdoor adventure, featuring iconic climbing areas like Montserrat, famous for its unique rock formations and spiritual significance. Climbers can enjoy both traditional and sport routes while immersing themselves in the city’s rich cultural scene.

Chamonix, France, is renowned for its dramatic peaks and challenging alpine climbs, attracting climbers from around the globe. The town serves as a base for accessing some of the most famous routes in the Mont Blanc Massif, offering both summer and winter climbing experiences.

Salt Lake City, Utah, is strategically located near a variety of climbing locations, making it a versatile spot for climbers of all skill levels. The Wasatch Range provides excellent bouldering, while the limestone cliffs of Little Cottonwood Canyon offer higher-grade sport climbing.

Victoria, Australia, boasts stunning coastal cliffs that are perfect for climbing, with areas like the Grampians and Mount Arapiles offering world-class routes. The region’s diverse climbing options cater to both sport and traditional climbers, all set against breathtaking natural landscapes.

How Do Local Climbing Communities Shape the Climbing Environment?

Event organization is key to fostering a sense of community and belonging among climbers. These events not only celebrate the sport but also raise awareness of the climbing community within the broader public, often attracting new climbers and tourists to the area.

Finally, networking and support systems within climbing communities are crucial for enhancing individual climber experiences. By connecting climbers through meet-ups and online forums, these communities ensure that climbers have access to partners, advice, and shared experiences that enrich their climbing journey.

What Are the Optimal Seasons for Climbing in Major Climbing Cities?

The optimal seasons for climbing vary based on the climate and geographical features of major climbing cities around the world.

  • Yosemite National Park, USA: The best climbing season is typically from late spring to early fall, particularly May through September.
  • Chamonix, France: The ideal time for climbing is during the summer months, from June to September, when the weather is most stable.
  • Rocklands, South Africa: Optimal climbing conditions are found during the southern hemisphere’s winter, from May to August, when temperatures are cooler and more comfortable.
  • El Chorro, Spain: The best climbing season is from late fall to early spring, particularly from October to April, when the weather is mild and dry.
  • Kalymnos, Greece: The peak climbing season is from late spring to early fall, especially from April to October, when the temperatures are warm but not excessively hot.
  • Joshua Tree, USA: The optimal climbing months are from October to April, when the weather is cooler and more pleasant for outdoor activities.

Yosemite National Park, USA: The best climbing season is typically from late spring to early fall, particularly May through September. During these months, climbers can enjoy mild weather and dry rock conditions, making it ideal for tackling iconic routes like El Capitan and Half Dome.

Chamonix, France: The ideal time for climbing in Chamonix is during the summer months, from June to September, when the weather is most stable. This period offers climbers access to high-altitude routes and the famed Mont Blanc massif, although it’s essential to be prepared for possible weather changes.

Rocklands, South Africa: Optimal climbing conditions are found during the southern hemisphere’s winter, from May to August, when temperatures are cooler and more comfortable. This season allows climbers to tackle bouldering problems in a stunning landscape without the oppressive heat of summer.

El Chorro, Spain: The best climbing season is from late fall to early spring, particularly from October to April, when the weather is mild and dry. This period allows climbers to explore the limestone cliffs and diverse routes without the scorching summer sun.

Kalymnos, Greece: The peak climbing season is from late spring to early fall, especially from April to October, when the temperatures are warm but not excessively hot. The island’s beautiful scenery and variety of climbing routes make it a popular destination during this time.

Joshua Tree, USA: The optimal climbing months are from October to April, when the weather is cooler and more pleasant for outdoor activities. Climbers can take advantage of the unique rock formations and diverse routes throughout the park without the sweltering heat typical of the summer months.

What Safety Considerations and Regulations Should Climbers Be Aware Of in These Cities?

Climbers should be aware of various safety considerations and regulations in climbing cities to ensure their safety and the preservation of climbing areas.

  • Local Regulations: Each climbing area often has specific regulations that climbers must follow, including access restrictions, seasonal closures, and designated routes. Understanding these rules helps maintain the natural environment and ensures a safe climbing experience.
  • Environmental Protection: Many climbing areas are located in sensitive ecological zones, so climbers should be conscious of Leave No Trace principles. This includes packing out all trash, staying on established trails, and avoiding damage to vegetation and wildlife habitats.
  • Safety Equipment: Climbers should use appropriate safety equipment such as helmets, harnesses, and ropes that meet safety standards. Regularly checking the condition of gear is essential to prevent accidents caused by equipment failure.
  • Weather Conditions: Climbers must stay informed about local weather patterns, as conditions can change rapidly in mountainous areas. Understanding how weather affects climbing conditions and being prepared for sudden changes can help avoid dangerous situations.
  • Climbing Etiquette: Practicing good climbing etiquette, such as yielding to other climbers and minimizing noise, fosters a positive climbing community. Respecting others also includes sharing routes and being aware of those around you to prevent accidents.
  • Emergency Preparedness: Climbers should carry a basic first aid kit and have a plan in case of emergencies, including knowing how to contact local authorities or rescue services. Familiarizing oneself with the area and potential hazards can significantly enhance safety.
Related Post:

Leave a Comment