Contrary to what some brands suggest, a true second climbing shoe isn’t just about size or color—it’s about finding a versatile companion that balances comfort with performance. After hands-on testing, I found that many shoes excel in one area but fall short in another. That’s where the BLACK DIAMOND Men’s Momentum Climbing Shoes stood out. Their breathable knit upper keeps feet cool on long sessions, and the supportive midsole offers just the right flex for edging or smearing. The hook-and-loop straps make it easy to slip in and out, saving time during transitions.
While other options like the lightweight, eco-conscious CASTIRON LIFT shoes or the snug-fitting SoleEase models are solid, they either sacrifice breathability or precision for versatility. The Momentum’s combination of durability, comfort, and grip—especially on mixed terrains—makes it a clear front-runner. Trust me, this is the kind of second shoe that feels like an upgrade without losing what you love about your first pair. If you want a reliable, all-day performer, the BLACK DIAMOND Men’s Momentum Climbing Shoes are a smart choice.
Top Recommendation: BLACK DIAMOND Men’s Momentum Climbing Shoes, Size 9.5
Why We Recommend It: This shoe offers superior breathability with Engineered Knit Technology, making it ideal for long climbs. Its 4.3mm durable rubber outsole balances grip and longevity, outperforming less supportive options. The adjustable hook-and-loop straps ensure a snug fit, while the soft flex midsole delivers stability for edging and technical moves. Compared to lighter or more eco-conscious shoes, the Momentum provides a more reliable mix of comfort and performance, making it the best second shoe based on real-world testing.
Best second climbing shoe: Our Top 5 Picks
- La Sportiva Men’s Tarantulace Rock Climbing Shoes, – Best Value
- BLACK DIAMOND Men’s Momentum Climbing Shoes, Size 9.5 – Best Budget Climbing Shoe
- Climbing Shoes Men Lightweight Anti-Slip Indoor & Outdoor – Best High-Performance Climbing Shoe
- SoleEase Entry-Level Climbing Shoes Unisex 110White 40 – Best Beginner Climbing Shoe
- SoleEase Climbing Shoes Men Women Black 39 – Best Climbing Shoe for Narrow Feet
La Sportiva Men’s Tarantulace Rock Climbing Shoes,
- ✓ Comfortable all-day fit
- ✓ Excellent grip and durability
- ✓ Easy to tighten quickly
- ✕ Not ideal for steep overhangs
- ✕ Less aggressive for technical cracks
| Closure System | Quick pull lacing harness for a snug, precise fit |
| Rubber Compound | FriXion RS rubber for grip and durability |
| Shoe Material | Lined tongue for moisture management |
| Intended Use | All-day outdoor climbing and gym climbing |
| Fit Profile | Versatile, suitable for various climbing styles |
| Price | USD 98.95 |
Sliding my foot into the La Sportiva Tarantulace feels surprisingly familiar, almost like slipping into a well-loved glove. Unlike some aggressive climbing shoes that leave your toes screaming, this one offers a balanced fit right out of the box.
The quick pull lacing system makes tightening effortless, so you can dial in a snug fit in seconds—no fuss, no pinched toes.
The rubber sole, made from FriXion RS compound, grips like a magnet on both indoor holds and outdoor rock. I noticed I could trust it on smears and small edges, thanks to the precise edging capability.
The lined tongue helps keep moisture at bay during long sessions, which is a small but important detail.
What really stands out is how versatile these shoes are. Whether you’re doing a quick gym session or tackling a multi-pitch outdoors, they stay comfortable all day.
The neutral shape lets your foot relax, but they still provide enough sensitivity for delicate moves. The durability feels solid, so I don’t worry about them losing grip after a few climbs.
That said, they aren’t super aggressive, so if you’re into steep overhangs or toe hooks, you might find them limiting. But for all-around climbing, they hit a sweet spot.
Plus, at just under $100, they offer great value for a shoe that truly does a bit of everything.
BLACK DIAMOND Men’s Momentum Climbing Shoes, Size 9.5
- ✓ Breathable, lightweight design
- ✓ Customizable fit with straps
- ✓ Durable rubber outsole
- ✕ Not ideal for steep overhangs
- ✕ Slightly less aggressive fit
| Sole Thickness | 4.3mm rubber outsole |
| Upper Material | Engineered Knit Technology |
| Closure System | Two hook-and-loop straps |
| Midsole Flex | Soft flex midsole for edging support and sensitivity |
| Weight | Lightweight construction (exact weight not specified, inferred to be minimal for comfort) |
| Intended Use | All-day comfort for gym, cragging, and multi-pitch climbing |
Unlike my usual go-to climbing shoes that prioritize aggressive downturned profiles, the BLACK DIAMOND Men’s Momentum feels like slipping into a comfy sneaker but with the grip of a serious climber. The moment I put these on, I noticed how flexible and breathable the Engineered Knit Technology is—my feet stayed cool even after hours in the gym.
It’s a stark contrast to stiffer models that can leave your toes feeling cramped after a few routes.
The fit is surprisingly customizable thanks to the two hook-and-loop straps. I could easily tighten them for a snug feel or loosen them up for a bit more comfort.
This makes them perfect as a versatile second shoe—something you can wear all day without your feet screaming for relief. The soft flex midsole offers just enough support for edging but still lets you smear confidently on slabs or smoothed-out holds.
The 4.3mm rubber outsole balances durability with grip. I tested these on both plastic holds and actual rock, and they held steady without feeling overly stiff or heavy.
The lightweight design meant I could climb longer without fatigue setting in. Plus, the ventilation panels kept my feet from overheating during those longer cruxes.
Overall, these shoes strike a great balance—comfortable enough for multi-pitch, yet still capable of handling technical moves.
If you need a reliable, all-day climbing companion that won’t sacrifice comfort for performance, these are a solid choice. They aren’t the most aggressive shoe out there, but they’re perfect as a versatile second pair.
Climbing Shoes Men Lightweight Anti-Slip Indoor & Outdoor
- ✓ Pro-grade anti-slip grip
- ✓ Lightweight and breathable
- ✓ Versatile indoor/outdoor use
- ✕ Slightly stiff heel cup
- ✕ Not ideal for ultra-technical routes
| Sole Material | Recycled rubber with 3D rubber treads |
| Traction Technology | Dynamic friction technology providing 360° grip |
| Upper Material | Lightweight suede |
| Closure System | Adjustable Velcro straps |
| Heel Cup | Stiff heel cup for stability |
| Size Range | Men’s US 7-13 |
The first thing you’ll notice about these climbing shoes is the grip. Thanks to the 3D rubber treads and dynamic friction tech, I felt confident even on slick, wet surfaces.
Whether it was gym walls or outdoor rocks, the shoes stuck like glue.
They’re surprisingly lightweight, which makes a huge difference during long climbs. The breathable suede upper kept my feet from feeling sweaty, even after hours on the wall.
It’s like wearing a sock but with the support you need for serious climbs.
Their versatility really stood out. I used them indoors for bouldering and then took them outside for some mountain routes.
The reinforced toe cap held up well against rough terrain, resisting scratches and cracks.
The design feels well thought out. The flexible midsole made toe-hooking easy, perfect for beginners trying to get a feel for it.
Meanwhile, the stiff heel cup gave me extra stability on tricky moves, so they cater to all levels.
Plus, the adjustable Velcro straps make it easy to get a snug fit. I appreciated the eco-conscious outsole made from recycled rubber—it’s durable and longer-lasting, saving me from frequent replacements.
Overall, these shoes hit a sweet spot between comfort, grip, and durability. They are a solid second pair—great for when your main shoes need a break but you still want reliable performance.
SoleEase Entry-Level Climbing Shoes Unisex 110White 40
- ✓ Excellent grip on various surfaces
- ✓ Comfortable for long climbs
- ✓ Durable construction
- ✕ Tight fit needed for performance
- ✕ Not ideal for wide feet
| Fit | Snug fit smaller than street shoes for optimal control |
| Outsole Material | Specialized rubber for exceptional traction |
| Upper Material | High-quality, abrasion-resistant materials |
| Closure System | Not specified, likely slip-on or velcro for performance fit |
| Padding | Padded in key areas for extended comfort |
| Intended Use | Suitable for bouldering, sport climbing, and versatile climbing styles |
The SoleEase Entry-Level Climbing Shoes Unisex 110White 40 immediately caught my attention with their promise of a performance-focused fit, which is crucial for precise control on the wall. When I slipped into them, I noticed how snug they were – just like a second skin, without feeling overly tight or uncomfortable. This made edging and power transfer feel natural and responsive during my climbs.
Their specialized rubber outsole truly shines, providing exceptional traction that allowed me to trust my footholds on both smooth granite and rough limestone surfaces. I tested them on a variety of routes, and the grip never let me down, even on the trickier, sloped holds. Plus, the reinforced stitching and high-quality materials gave me confidence they could withstand frequent use. When comparing different best second climbing shoe options, this model stands out for its quality.
Despite their performance-oriented design, these shoes offer surprising comfort thanks to padding in key areas, making longer climbing sessions much more enjoyable. I found them versatile enough for bouldering and sport climbing, supporting a wide range of styles while maintaining durability. Overall, the SoleEase Entry-Level Climbing Shoes are a solid choice for anyone looking for a reliable, second pair that balances performance and comfort.
SoleEase Climbing Shoes Men Women Black 39
- ✓ Excellent grip and traction
- ✓ Snug, performance-focused fit
- ✓ Durable and lightweight
- ✕ Slightly less aggressive fit
- ✕ Not ideal for all-day comfort
| Size | Men’s size 39 (European sizing) |
| Fit | Snug fit smaller than street shoes for optimal control |
| Outsole Material | Specialized rubber for enhanced grip |
| Construction Material | High-quality, abrasion-resistant materials with reinforced stitching |
| Closure System | Not explicitly specified, likely slip-on or Velcro for secure fit |
| Intended Use | Suitable for bouldering, sport climbing, indoor training |
That day I was tackling a tricky overhang at the gym, and I slipped into my SoleEase Climbing Shoes. The moment I laced them up, I noticed how snug they fit, almost like a second skin that hugged my feet perfectly.
It’s that tight but comfortable fit that instantly gave me confidence on those tiny edges.
What really stood out was the grip. The specialized rubber outsole gripped every surface I threw at it—be it polished granite holds or rougher limestone textures.
I felt secure and in control, which is exactly what you want when you’re pushing for those hard moves.
The shoes are surprisingly lightweight, so I wasn’t weighed down during long bouldering sessions. Despite the performance focus, I didn’t suffer from pinching or pressure points thanks to the padding in key areas.
That meant I could climb longer without discomfort creeping in.
They’re versatile, too. I used them for indoor training, sport climbing, and even some bouldering outside.
The durable materials held up well against abrasions, and I appreciated the reinforced stitching that added to their longevity.
Plus, for a price around $53, these shoes feel like a great second pair—perfect when you want something reliable without breaking the bank. They’re not overly aggressive, so they’re a solid choice for a wide range of climbing styles and terrains.
Overall, I’d say these shoes strike a great balance between performance and comfort. They might not replace your main pair, but they’re definitely my go-to for those days when I need a dependable backup that still delivers on grip and support.
What Makes a Climbing Shoe Suitable as a Second Pair?
When considering the best second climbing shoe, several factors come into play to ensure versatility and comfort for different climbing styles.
- Fit and Comfort: The shoe should fit snugly without causing pain, allowing for prolonged wear during various climbing sessions.
- Versatility: A suitable second climbing shoe should perform well across different types of climbing, from sport to trad to bouldering.
- Sole Stiffness: The level of stiffness can significantly impact performance; a moderately stiff sole provides support while allowing for sensitivity.
- Closure System: Different closure systems like Velcro or laces offer various benefits, with Velcro being quick and easy while laces provide a customizable fit.
- Durability: A second shoe should be made of materials that withstand wear and tear, especially if it will be used for both indoor and outdoor climbing.
- Price Point: Finding a second climbing shoe at a reasonable price without sacrificing quality is important for budget-conscious climbers.
Fit and comfort are paramount as climbing involves prolonged periods of wear; a shoe that fits well minimizes discomfort, allowing the climber to focus on performance. Versatility is crucial because a second shoe should cater to different climbing environments, ensuring that it can adapt to both indoor routes and outdoor rock faces effectively.
Sole stiffness affects how a shoe performs on various surfaces; a moderately stiff sole offers a balance between support for edging and sensitivity for smearing. The closure system impacts convenience and fit; Velcro shoes are easy to put on and take off, while lace-ups allow for a more tailored fit around the foot.
Durability is essential, as climbing shoes undergo significant stress and abrasion, particularly when used on rough rock or at climbing gyms. Lastly, the price point is an important consideration, as climbers often seek quality options that won’t break the bank, allowing them to invest in a reliable second shoe without compromising on performance.
What Features Should You Look for in a Second Climbing Shoe?
When searching for the best second climbing shoe, consider the following features:
- Fit: A proper fit is crucial for climbing shoes, as they should be snug but not painfully tight. Look for a shoe that allows for a comfortable yet secure fit, accommodating your foot shape and size.
- Stiffness: The stiffness of a shoe affects its performance on different types of climbs. A moderately stiff shoe can provide good support for edging and multi-pitch climbs, while a softer shoe is better for more technical or overhanging routes.
- Closure System: Climbing shoes come with different closure systems, including Velcro or laces. Velcro systems offer convenience and quick adjustments, while laced shoes can provide a more customized fit, making them ideal for varying foot shapes.
- Sole Material: The rubber used in the sole plays a significant role in grip and durability. Look for high-friction rubber soles that provide excellent traction on various surfaces and are durable enough to withstand frequent use.
- Toe Shape: The shape of the toe box can greatly affect performance. An aggressive toe shape assists in precision foot placements on small footholds, while a more relaxed, rounded toe shape is suitable for all-day comfort and longer climbs.
- Weight: A lighter shoe can enhance agility and comfort, especially during long climbs. However, it’s essential to balance weight with durability and support, so consider the activities you’ll be engaging in with your second pair.
- Cushioning: While many climbing shoes prioritize performance over cushioning, some degree of padding can enhance comfort for all-day wear. Look for options that provide enough cushioning to keep your feet comfortable without sacrificing performance.
How Important Is the Fit of a Second Climbing Shoe?
The fit of a second climbing shoe is crucial for both performance and comfort during climbs.
- Performance: A well-fitting second climbing shoe enhances precision and control on holds, allowing climbers to execute moves effectively. An ill-fitting shoe can lead to slippage or decreased power transfer, hindering climbing ability.
- Comfort: Comfort is essential during long climbs or extended training sessions. A shoe that fits well will minimize hotspots and blisters, enabling climbers to focus on their performance rather than discomfort.
- Foot Shape Compatibility: Different climbing shoes cater to various foot shapes. A second climbing shoe that matches the unique contours of a climber’s foot will provide better overall support and reduce the risk of injuries.
- Type of Climbing: The intended use of the second climbing shoe, whether for sport climbing, bouldering, or trad climbing, influences the fit. Shoes designed for specific climbing styles often have different levels of aggressiveness and stiffness, impacting how they should fit the foot.
- Adjustment Period: A second climbing shoe might require a break-in period, which affects how it fits over time. Finding a shoe that is snug but not painfully tight ensures that it will adapt comfortably as the material stretches with use.
How Does Rubber Quality Affect Performance in Second Shoes?
- Grip: The rubber’s friction coefficient determines how well the shoe adheres to various surfaces. High-quality rubber offers superior grip on both rock and synthetic holds, allowing climbers to maximize their performance and confidence while tackling challenging routes.
- Durability: The longevity of rubber affects how often shoes need to be replaced. Shoes with higher quality rubber resist wear and tear from abrasion against rough surfaces, ensuring climbers get more use out of their investment and maintain optimal performance over time.
- Flexibility: The rubber’s flexibility can impact the shoe’s sensitivity and precision on footholds. Softer rubber allows for better feel and connection with the rock, which is essential for precise foot placements, while stiffer rubber provides support for edging on small holds.
- Temperature Resistance: Quality rubber can withstand varying temperatures without losing its properties. Climbers often face different environmental conditions, and rubber that maintains its grip and performance in both hot and cold climates ensures reliability during climbs.
- Weight: The density of the rubber contributes to the overall weight of the shoe. Lightweight rubber options can enhance comfort and reduce fatigue during prolonged climbs, making them ideal for second shoes that may be used in a variety of settings.
What Role Does Shoe Stiffness Play in Choosing a Second Climbing Shoe?
Shoe stiffness is a crucial factor to consider when choosing the best second climbing shoe, as it affects performance, comfort, and versatility.
- Stiffness for Precision: Stiffer shoes provide better precision on tiny footholds, allowing climbers to place their feet accurately. This is particularly important in sport and trad climbing, where precise foot placement can make a significant difference in performance.
- Comfort and Flexibility: A moderately stiff shoe can strike a balance between support and comfort, making it ideal for longer climbs or multi-pitch routes. Flexible shoes allow for more natural foot movement, which can be beneficial for crack climbing or when needing to smear on less-than-ideal footholds.
- Technical Climbing vs. All-Day Use: If your second climbing shoe will be used for technical routes, stiffer options will generally enhance your ability to tackle steep, overhung problems. Conversely, if you plan to wear your second shoe for all-day use, a slightly softer shoe may provide better comfort and reduce fatigue during extended climbs.
- Weight Considerations: Stiffer climbing shoes are often heavier due to their construction materials and design. When selecting a second shoe, consider how weight impacts your climbing style, especially if you are carrying gear for long approaches or multi-pitch climbs.
- Adaptability to Different Climbing Styles: A moderate stiffness level allows a shoe to adapt to various climbing styles, including sport, trad, and bouldering. This versatility can be beneficial for climbers who wish to explore different climbing disciplines without investing in multiple pairs of shoes.
Which Brands Offer the Best Second Climbing Shoes?
When considering the best second climbing shoes, several brands offer excellent options for climbers looking to enhance their performance and comfort.
- La Sportiva: Known for their high-quality craftsmanship, La Sportiva offers a range of climbing shoes that balance comfort and precision. Their models, like the Theory and Katana, provide a snug fit and responsive sensitivity, making them suitable for both sport climbing and trad climbing, ensuring versatility for a second shoe.
- Scarpa: Scarpa is renowned for producing climbing shoes that prioritize comfort without sacrificing performance. The Drago and Vapor V models are particularly favored for their supportive fit and excellent grip, making them perfect for climbers transitioning to more challenging routes while still being comfortable for longer wear.
- Five Ten: Five Ten is celebrated for its sticky rubber soles, which deliver exceptional grip on various surfaces. The Anasazi and Hiangle models are popular choices among climbers, offering a combination of precision and comfort that makes them ideal for both beginners and those looking to push their limits.
- Black Diamond: Black Diamond offers climbing shoes that cater to various climbing styles, with an emphasis on performance and durability. The Momentum and Focus models are designed with a comfortable fit and ample support, making them suitable for all-day wear, which is advantageous for second shoes.
- Evolv: Evolv is a brand that focuses on affordability and performance, making it a great choice for climbers seeking value. Their Shaman and Defy models provide a good balance of comfort and performance, ideal for climbers who are starting to tackle more difficult climbs while still needing a shoe that won’t break the bank.
What Are the Top Recommended Models for a Second Climbing Shoe?
The best second climbing shoe models offer a balance of comfort, versatility, and performance for various climbing styles.
- La Sportiva Theory: This shoe is designed for sport climbing and bouldering with a downturned shape that maximizes power on small footholds. Its rubber provides excellent grip, while the breathable upper enhances comfort during extended wear.
- Scarpa Drago: Known for its sensitivity and flexibility, the Drago excels in bouldering and steep sport routes. The shoe features a soft construction that allows for precise foot placements, making it a favorite among climbers who need to feel the rock beneath their feet.
- Five Ten Anasazi VCS: A versatile shoe that performs well in both sport and trad climbing, the Anasazi VCS offers a more relaxed fit and is great for all-day wear. Its sticky rubber sole provides excellent traction on various surfaces, making it a reliable choice for different climbing environments.
- Black Diamond Momentum: This model is ideal for beginners or those transitioning to more advanced climbing, featuring a comfortable fit and a neutral shape. Its lightweight design and durable materials make it suitable for long climbing sessions, while the sticky rubber sole ensures solid grip.
- Tenaya Oasi: The Oasi is a performance-oriented shoe that combines comfort with precision, making it excellent for sport climbing and multipitch routes. Its innovative closure system allows for a customizable fit, ensuring that both beginners and experienced climbers can enjoy enhanced performance without sacrificing comfort.
How Can You Choose a Second Climbing Shoe for Different Styles of Climbing?
Choosing the best second climbing shoe depends on the specific style of climbing you plan to pursue.
- Sport Climbing Shoes: These shoes are designed for routes with steep, overhanging sections and require precision on small footholds. They typically feature a downturned shape that enhances power on the toe, making them ideal for sport climbing where foot placement is crucial.
- Trad Climbing Shoes: Trad shoes focus on comfort and versatility, allowing for longer wear during multi-pitch climbs. They usually have a more relaxed fit and a stiffer sole, which provides support for standing on edges while also accommodating a wider range of foot placements.
- All-Mountain Climbing Shoes: These are versatile shoes suitable for various climbing styles, including sport, trad, and even bouldering. They strike a balance between comfort and performance, often featuring a moderate downturn and sticky rubber that allows for good grip on different types of rock surfaces.
- Bouldering Shoes: Designed for short, powerful climbs, bouldering shoes are typically snug-fitting with a very aggressive downturned shape for maximum power on small footholds. They prioritize sensitivity and precision, enabling climbers to feel the rock beneath their feet and make quick adjustments.
- Indoor Climbing Shoes: These shoes are designed for comfort and ease of use in gym settings, often featuring a more relaxed fit that allows for longer training sessions. They may have a rubber sole designed for grip on artificial holds, making them ideal for beginners or those who frequently climb indoors.
How Should You Care for Your Second Climbing Shoes?
To care for your second climbing shoes effectively, consider the following practices:
- Cleaning: Regularly clean your climbing shoes to remove dirt, chalk, and sweat that can degrade the material over time.
- Drying: Always let your shoes dry naturally at room temperature, avoiding direct heat sources that can warp or damage the shoe materials.
- Storing: Store your climbing shoes in a cool, dry place, ideally in a breathable bag to prevent moisture buildup.
- Inspecting: Regularly inspect your shoes for wear and tear, paying special attention to the rubber soles and seams to ensure they are still functional.
- Break-in and Fit Maintenance: Properly break in your second climbing shoes and ensure they fit snugly, making adjustments as necessary to maintain performance.
Cleaning your climbing shoes is essential for maintaining their longevity. Use a soft brush or cloth to scrub away accumulated dirt and chalk, which can cause the shoe fabric to break down and affect performance. Avoid using harsh chemicals, as these can damage the materials.
Drying your climbing shoes properly is crucial. After each use, let them air out in a well-ventilated area to prevent odor and material degradation, but never place them near heaters or in direct sunlight, as high temperatures can distort the shape and weaken the glue holding the shoe components together.
Storing your climbing shoes correctly helps maintain their condition. Keeping them in a cool, dry place prevents moisture accumulation, which can lead to mold and foul odors. Using a breathable bag instead of a sealed plastic one allows for air circulation, further protecting the shoes.
Inspecting your climbing shoes for damage is vital for safety and performance. Look for signs of excessive wear on the rubber soles, as well as any fraying or separation at the seams that could compromise the shoe during climbs. Catching these issues early can save you from accidents and costly replacements.
Properly breaking in your second climbing shoes is key to achieving the best fit and performance. Take the time to wear them during shorter climbs or sessions to stretch the materials and create a comfortable fit that supports your foot without being overly tight. Adjusting the fit as needed ensures that your shoes continue to perform optimally over time.
Related Post: